Paula Dockery for Governor

Archive | Uncategorized

TOP GOP US SENATE CANDIDATES DEBATE IN ORLANDO. McCalister defends record.

Posted on 25 August 2011 by admin

by Jim Smithson

(Orlando) The top leading candidates for the GOP nomination meet for their first in what will be many debates leading up to the GOP primary for the US Senate.

The winner of the primary in August 2012 will face longtime incumbent US Senator Bill Nelson for the seat in November of 2012.

Candidates; Colonel Rick McCalister, Adam Hasner, George LaMieux and Craig Miller debated the issues at a local Orlando school for several hours.

According to my observers, Colonel McCalister made a positive impression among the conservative, Christian-crowd.

Following the debate, a Miami Herald reporter accused Col. McCalister of not telling the truth about an appearance before a congressional panel.  McCalister offered this response: “When serving at the United Special Operations Command (USSOCOM) in Tampa, I had the opportunity to accompany the Deputy Commander, Lieutenant General (LTG) W. P. Tangney, as the Subject Matter Expert to a hearing. The Army, like all other branches of the military, work as a team. I sat under the bright Capitol lights with General Tangney, who relied upon my research and counsel to give accurate testimony to Congress.  In fact, my Senior Rater, LTG Tangney wrote in my April 2002 Officer Evaluation Report (OER) that I “led the USSOCOM team at congressional hearing on military readiness, assisting [LTG Tangney] greatly in the testimony…” “Because of the high visibility study, [McCalister] was tasked with serving as subject matter expert for U.S. congressional testimony on Military Readiness and National Security.”

McCalister has served in the Army National Guard, Army Reserves, and on Active Duty for a total of 33 years between 1971 and 2005.

 

 

Share

Comments (0)

Borrowing a campaign tactic from a Democrat, GOP Senate candidate pledges to do workdays.

Posted on 25 July 2011 by admin

Former Ruth’s Chris Steak House CEO Chris Miller launched his bid for the U.S. Senate today. (Photo by Michael Freeman).
ORLANDO – The problem with politicians today, Craig Miller believes, is they’re out of touch with what regular workers and small business owners are going through in these challenging economic times.
“I built a successful restaurant career by talking to people in the back door of my restaurant,” said Miller, a resident of Winter Park, who has worked for restaurant chains like Red Lobster, Uno and Ruth’s Chris Steak House. He led that last company through four years of record growth and profits as its president and chief executive officer, and later served as Florida’s tourism commissioner in 2007 under Gov. Jeb Bush.
This morning, Miller announced he was running for the U.S. Senate next year, seeking the Republican nomination so he can challenge two-term Democratic Sen. Bill Nelson in 2012. Miller said his campaign would be based on bringing common sense back to Washington, improving the economy by lifting burdensome regulations and taxes off the shoulders of struggling businesses, and, most importantly, connecting with average workers by learning exactly what they do for a living.
And to do that, he announced a plan called “Miller on Main Street” – his effort to learn first hand what average workers do every day to pay their bills.
“I’m here today to announce a new initiative,” Miller said during a press conference at the Courtyard by Marriott in downtown Orlando. “It’s designed to keep me engaged with the people, to find out what goes on in the real world. If you’re going to represent the people of Florida, you have to be connected to the people of Florida.”
Miller said he would work a normal shift twice a month starting this month, and he would continue to do this through the end of his first six-year term in the Senate. Along the way, he said, he would listen to the concerns of hard-working Floridians and learn from them, on what are expected to be 178 trips down “Main Street.”
“Staying in tune with those concerns is paramount,” he said, adding that all too often, politicians head to Washington and forgot about what their constituents really care about. There’s no better example of that, he said, than the ongoing fight in Congress over whether to raise the ceiling on the debt limit to pay the nation’s bills.
“We’ve created a false crisis that has jeopardized our economic vitality,” Miller said. “We’re dealing with a false crisis, a debt ceiling crisis.”
Instead, he proposed a “short term fix” that included an across the board $2 drop in federal spending, balanced out by a $1 increase in the debt ceiling.
If Miller’s Main Street plan sounds familiar, it is. Former governor and U.S. Sen. Bob Graham, a Democrat, did the same thing in his first statewide campaign in 1978, when he called it “Workdays.” Miller said that while he and Graham represent different parties, he always liked the idea and felt Graham demonstrated that he understood the concerns of common people.
“You need to get out on Main Street and spend a little time working with regular people,” he said. “Good ideas come from all walks of life. I thought even back then, ‘What a great idea.’ “
Miller said one of his top priorities would be to spur stronger job growth by making it easier for businesses to invest in new workers.
“We’re in a cycle now that’s very challenging for job creations,” he said. “Where I would start would be to do everything we can to lower regulation and taxes, and taxes on consumers.”
Raising taxes now, he said, would be “taking money off Main Street.”
He also encouraged small business owners to hire him for a day, by logging on to www.Miller2012.com.
“If you’re a small business out there and are interested in having me work for you for a day, go to my web site,” he said. “What I’d really like to see is the small business community come forward and take an interest in what I’m doing. If you want something out of life, you have to work for it.”
Miller won’t have a clear shot at the GOP nomination, which has already attracted a crowded field that includes former U.S. Sen. George LeMieux, ex-Florida House Majority Leader Adam Hasner, 2010 gubernatorial candidate Mike McCalister, businessman Ron Rushing, and state Senate President Mike Haridopolos.
Political consultant Doug Guetzloe, host of The Guetzloe Report radio show on the Phoenix Network, predicted that Miller could emerge as the strongest GOP nominee, and said he has a good shot at ending up as the candidate who takes on Nelson.
“With Miller, you have a proven track record of business accomplishment and of actually creating jobs,” said Guetzloe, a veteran of hundreds of statewide and local campaigns in Florida. “None of the other GOP candidates can make that claim.”
Nelson won his first term in the U.S. Senate in 2000 with 51 percent of the vote, defeating Congressman Bill McCollum. He was reelected with 61 percent in 2006 against former Secretary of State Katherine Harris.
This race has been ranked as a potentially competitive one, but not among the tightest races in the nation next year. The Cook Political Report ranks this race as “Leans Democrat,” meaning the Democratic incumbent is vulnerable but still has a slight advantage.
Another leading political analyst site, Larry Sabato’s Crystal Ball, also ranks the race as “Leans Democrat.”
Written by: Freeline Media for Freeline Media on July 21, 2011.

 

Share

Comments (0)

GOP Senate Frontrunner, Craig Miller comments on Haridopolos Decision to drop US Senate bid

Posted on 25 July 2011 by admin

ORLANDO – U.S. Senate candidate Craig Miller issued the following statement regarding Senate President Mike Haridopolos’ withdrawal from the Republican primary: “This must have been a difficult decision for Mike and Stephanie. Mike should be applauded for dedicating himself to his current position and continuing to serve the constituents who elected him. While I am certain that those who supported his campaign will be disappointed, I believe they will also respect the tough choice Mike made to put the needs of all Floridians first.”
Craig Miller began his restaurant career in the dish room as a teenager and rose to become a successful businessman, creating over 40,000 jobs at several well-known restaurant chains like Red Lobster, Pizzeria Uno, and Ruth’s Chris.  He served as Chairman of the National Restaurant Association and was named Operator of the Year in 2007 by Nation’s Restaurant News.  Miller is a veteran of the United States Air Force, having volunteered to serve in Vietnam in 1969.  He is the father of three, a proud grandfather and resides in Winter Park with his wife, Susan.

 

Share

Comments (0)

My Word: No to referendum in Seminole

Posted on 18 July 2011 by admin

By Sean Concannon July 13, 2011

The Orlando Sentinel on Sunday published an editorial proclaiming that “Seminole voters deserve the chance to renew the county’s penny sales tax” (“Let the public decide”).

However, Seminole voters just declined a proposal by the Seminole County School Board to impose a half-penny sales tax this past November. The past referendum campaigns have promoted the sales tax as primarily benefiting the schools and utilized access to school resources and supporters to promote the extra sales tax. Since voters just recently rejected a sales tax exclusively for the schools, we do not need another referendum to renew the penny sales tax.

Absent a favorable vote on the tax, the taxes will drop back to the statewide rate of 6 percent. Any new tax is an increase from that statewide rate, even in the worst math classrooms imaginable. Regardless of when another sales-tax referendum takes place, it would still be a tax increase. The question is only a political one as to how the taxpayers perceive impact of the new tax. The difference is that people will more readily see the increase on their receipts if the tax vote is put off until after November.

Of course, there are other reasons for proponents to support a special election this November rather than at the next general election. Tax supporters understand that turnout for a special election will be low because many people will be blissfully ignorant of the impending new tax. The tax supporters will make sure the direct beneficiaries are well-informed through the school system and government employees unions.  

As usual, the concentrated benefits to the few will outweigh the costs to the majority, and opposition will likely be limited.




The truth is that government at all levels has a history of spending too much, and in Florida it spent with abandon as property values were rising, rather than controlling the growth of government. Responsible officials would have foreseen at least the possibility that revenues might fall.

Now taxpayers are expected to support tax increases even after revenues have risen dramatically. From the 2000-01 budget to 2008-09, the tax revenues went from $15.4 billion to $34.4 billion, a 123 percent increase.

How many businesses and families in Seminole County could boast that increase in income for the same service? Whining about millions in cuts out of billions in the total budget is just not a good justification for new taxes.

Sean Concannon of Longwood is former deputy treasurer for Six for Seminole political action committee.

 

Share

Comments (0)

Craig Miller Announces Bid to Unseat 40-Year Politician Nelson

Posted on 15 July 2011 by admin

Business Leader’s Campaign Announcement Sets
Stage for “Main Street v. Pennsylvania Avenue” Battle

ORLANDO – Craig Miller, a successful businessman and Air Force veteran, today launched his campaign to be the next United States Senator from the state of Florida.  Miller, a Republican, announced his plans by flying around the state, making stops in Orlando, Tampa, Naples, West Palm Beach and Jacksonville.

In announcing his bid, Miller stated, “As someone who’s been in the restaurant business for forty years, I’ve learned first-hand that if you’re going to be successful, you have to listen to–and take care of–both your employees and your customers.  As such, I’ve met with and listened to Floridians across the state who tell me government is too big, too intrusive, takes too much of their hard-earned money, spends their money wastefully, and is hurting the economy and destroying jobs.”

Miller continued, “Voters also tell me they are fed up with a government dominated by career politicians who’ve never worked a day in the private sector and are completely out of touch with Main Street.”

“I’m proud to have answered our country’s call over 30 years ago when I enlisted in the Air Force and volunteered to go to Vietnam.  And it will be an honor to serve my fellow Americans again in the United States Senate.”

“This campaign is going to be one that pits someone who will fight for Floridians who live on Main Street against a 40-year incumbent politician who has repeatedly bowed to the liberal agenda of those on Pennsylvania Avenue.”

“I’ve spent the last forty years paying attention to what’s happening on Main Street because that’s where people live.  It’s where they shop, it’s where they dine out, it’s where they send their kids to school and where they raise their families.  Main Street is home for Floridians.”

“Bill Nelson has forgotten where Main Street is because he’s spent the last forty years trying to further his political career, running for political office after political office after political office.  Nelson is so out-of-touch that he doesn’t care or recognize the hurtful impact his votes for President Obama’s liberal agenda have had on folks back home who are just trying to make ends meet.”

40-Year Incumbent Politician Bill Nelson Has …
Voted For President Obama’s Position 97% Of The Time. (Congressional Quarterly, www.cq.com, Accessed 2/18/11)

Supported Cap And Trade Legislation That Could Destroy 66,000 Florida Jobs Over The Next Two Decades And Raise Electricity Bills By $800 Per Household. (S. 3036, CQ Vote #145: Rejected 48-36: R 7-32; D 39-4; I 2-0, 6/6/08, Nelson Voted Yea and Kreutzer, David, et al, “Impact Of The Waxman-Markey Climate Change Legislation To Florida,” The Heritage Foundation, 8/19/09)

Voted For The Health Care Reconciliation Bill Which Cut Medicare $500 Million Over The Next Decade. (H.R. 4872, CQ Vote #105: Passed 56-43: R 0-40; D 54-3; I 2-0, 3/25/10, Nelson Voted Yea; Lori Montgomery and Paul Kane, “House Leaders Announce $940 Billion Health-Care Compromise Bill,” The Washington Post, 3/19/10)

Voted For President Obama’s Failed So-Called “Stimulus” Bill. (H.R. 1, CQ Vote #64: Adopted 60-38; R 3-38; D 55-0; I 2-0, 2/13/09, Nelson Voted Yea)

Voted For The Fannie Mae And Freddie Mac Bailout. (H.R. 3221, CQ Vote #186: Motion Agreed To, Thus Clearing The Bill For The President 72-13: R 27-13; D 43-0; I 2-0, 7/26/08, Nelson Voted Yea)

Craig Miller began his restaurant career in the dish room as a teenager and rose to become a successful businessman, creating over 40,000 jobs at several well-known restaurant chains like Red Lobster, Pizzeria Uno, and Ruth’s Chris.  He served as Chairman of the National Restaurant Association and was named Operator of the Year in 2007 by Nation’s Restaurant News.  Miller is a veteran of the United States Air Force, having volunteered to serve in Vietnam in 1969.  He is the father of three, a proud grandfather and resides in Winter Park with his wife, Susan.

Share

Comments (0)

Conservative businessman to run for US Senate

Posted on 11 July 2011 by admin

On Tuesday, Republican Craig Miller, a businessman, Vietnam veteran and 2010 congressional candidate will be holding press availabilities during a statewide fly-around to announce his plans regarding the 2012 United States Senate race. He will be making stops in Orlando, Tampa, Naples, West Palm Beach and Jacksonville. The events will include brief remarks from Craig and follow-up Q&A from press.

Miller 2012: Itinerary for July 12 Announcement Fly-Around

8:00am – Press Availability at Orlando International Airport

Galaxy Aviation

9245 Tradeport Drive

Orlando, FL 32827

Facilities Contact: Kristen Scherzer – 800-704-4147

10:00am – Press Availability at Tampa International Airport

Signature Flight Support

2450 N. Westshore Boulevard

Tampa, FL 33607

Facilities Contact: Scott Nixon – 813-425-8912

12:00pm – Press Availability at Naples Municipal Airport

160 Aviation Drive North

Naples, FL 34104

Facilities Contact: Sue Heart – 239-643-0733

2:30pm – Press Availability at Palm Beach International Airport

Galaxy Aviation

4149 Southern Boulevard

West Balm Peach, FL 33406

Facilities Contact: Laurel England – 561-686-6887

5:00pm – Press Availability at Jacksonville International Airport

Shelt Air

4600 Whirlwind Avenue

Jacksonville, FL 32218

Facilities Contact: Jonathan Buff – 904-476-8080

 

 

Share

Comments (0)

THINGS ARE WORSE THEN YOU MAY THINK!

Posted on 30 June 2011 by admin

Make no mistake this is not about “liberals vs conservatives”, or Republicans vs the Democrats,     It’s about what is right, and what is wrong.  The legislation and policies of the Governor and legislative leadership are WRONG.

It’s about shouting a warning to Floridians that their elected leaders are selling them down the river, saying one thing, but doing another.

In 16 years in the Florida House, Senate and Public Service Commission,  I have tried  to inform  people about what was going on in their government, provided the inside scoop that political leaders did not want you to know about.  I have been warning for years, and providing examples of our representative government/democracy being sold to the highest contributors, the slush funds, the corruption.  That it really is about money.

I have been a Republican, and believe in the republican principles of long ago:  Less government in my private life;   don’t tax us to death; personal freedom; personal responsibility; the right to protect myself and family; and for allowing business to do what it does best, do business, without excessive or unnecessary regulations.  But in the last, and contrary to the current crop of Republican leaders, I do not want Halliburton in charge of the Pentagon, BP heading up the Department of Environmental Protection, Enron making energy policy.

In recent years I have seen exactly the opposite of that philosophy and I have seen much corruption.  So much so that the Grand Jury ranked Florida number one in corruption.

I have a problem with those who have hijacked the Republican party to use it for their own self gain,  who wouldn’t have a clue what an Republican platform is and who have mutated the R philosophy beyond recognition.   I take offense that they use the hard working grassroots level republicans to help promote a philosophy that they do not practice.   Many good republicans that worked hard for this party have written books telling us what was happening, apparently to no avail.  It cannot be that all that matters is that our side wins at any cost. I refuse to believe anyone could not see the harm in doing that.

Seems that anytime an elected republican official would not go along with the crooks that stole the party, they were labeled as Republicans in name only (RINO’s) and that tactic worked for awhile.  This has brought the R party to the sad place where I see it is now.  Fractured.

As a Republican I cannot be proud of the party Chairman being carted off in handcuffs and accused of stealing contributions.  I cannot be proud of or defend R leaders abusing the party credit cards for things like lingerie for girlfriends, home repairs, trips to Vegas and more.

I will not defend the R senate President who stridently squawks for smaller government yet has taken three government salaries, tax paid, ostensibly as a professor, not to teach, but to take three years to write a book on politics, achieving a kindergarten level of literacy of which the college only had one single copy of.   I have sat next to this legislator in committees when serious discussion was taking place only to watch him write greeting and B-day cards to his constituents for political purposes, totally oblivious of the discussions going on. For years legislative leaders obtained for certain legislators these extra “jobs” in return for a “do everything you’re told” legislator.  Pretty hard for those legislators to object when they have gotten used to the trough, even when it hurts the very people who have voted for them.

I cannot be proud of legislation proposed and passed this session that strips away minimum protections for our elderly in tax payer subsidized for-profit nursing homes, legislation which turns them into elder fodder for over paid executives and coupon clipping shareholders.  One of my biggest battles in the legislature as Chair of the House Elder Affairs and Long Term Care Committee , was to bring nursing home quality of care standards merely up to the federal minimum safety levels.   I recall a influential owner of a large nursing home chain telling me he could not provide those minimum standards and also provide the money his shareholders and executives demanded.

I am not proud of the firing of the Long Term Care Ombudsman who was doing a great job and was supported by nursing home resident family members.   I am not proud of the reduced funding for Medicaid supported poor elderly while reducing the minimum required staffing levels I fought so hard to get into law.  All this while further curbs on civil litigation in redressing nursing home horrors passed.

The attempt to privatize everything government does is alive and well, under the premise of “efficiency “ and while some privitizations work well,  not all do.  After all, the mission of government, contrary to the booming proclamations of self absorbed politicians, is, among other notable goals, to promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of liberty, not to grease the profit avenues of significant campaign contributors.  Privatization makes for more, and larger contribution sources.

As Chair of the Senate Governmental Operations Committee, I saw first hand how tax payers got ripped off by some of the major privatized contracts.  My committee had to fix the huge errors in contracts, and found they came at a very high cost to the tax payer.  Although a company bid low and won the contract, embedded in many contracts were automatic increases that most times had us paying a much higher price for the service then when provided by the state, and the most elementary protections one would expect to find in contracts were removed.

I am yet more ashamed of the massive deregulation bills that passed this session.   Attacks on water laws, the environment, and all out “build it wherever and however you want it”approach to growth.

For the last 16 yrs the republican majority deregulated where it was called for, removing unnecessary, duplicative measures.  The recent bills are simply giveaways and will cause great harm.

I cannot be proud of the attacks on our teachers and state workers, firefighters, police the environment and even election laws.  I had in my senate district a state firefighter whose salary was such that he qualified for food stamps when his wife was expecting a second child. To legislators who fashioned bills for drug testing state workers, here’s an idea:  eliminate the exceptions for executive and legislative staff, and members of the House and Senate.

I am ashamed of the relentless intrusion into personal decisions in people’s personal lives, despite Republican leaderships mantra that government be minimal

Not proud that millions were hidden in the 2006 budget to get an airport hangar that a big contributor and friend of the Republican Speaker wanted.  I am incensed that a  Jeb Bush DCA appointee who managed to squander tax dollars in outfitting the Tajh Mahal courthouse with the mahogany furniture, flat screen TVs and expensive art work, while we are laying off people and cutting essential services, but also managed to so overstep his authority that he has been ethically indicted by the JQC.

Attacks on citizen’s ballot initiatives, only to find that the biggest abusers of the constitutional amendment process are the legislators themselves, and for political purposes.

They are even fighting the majority of citizens (63%) who voted for a ballot initiative for fair districts with our own tax dollars ($50,000,000).   I cannot be proud to find that the Fl. Speaker has hired his own law firm to litigate the Fair Districts amendment challenges.

Sheer arrogance.

For a party ostensibly consumed by economic efficiency, the CSX sweetheart deal which costs us millions and puts operational liability on tax payers, is inexplicable, except to the extent that its been reported a key legislator has property that will benefit from the deal..

You all know what the legislative leaders did to PSC commissioners who said no to unjustified electric rate increases.  The PSC is a legislative agency that does what the legislature wants it to do.  Legislative leaders don’t want a fair PSC, they want a kept whore.  Legislative leaders take millions from those the PSC regulates, do you really think you are getting a fair shake?  This agency will continue to be a waste of tax dollars until it is removed from the legislatures control.

The usurpation of PSC responsibilities by the legislature is reflected by the amendment sneaked into the  energy bill that passed in 2006 by the soon to be senate president.  When the bill came to the floor it was never mentioned-as used to be custom- that substantial and major policy changes had been introduced, and we all voted for it.     Republican leadership slipped us a Mickey at the behest of the utility lobby. Now with nuclear under the gun, both socially because of Fukushima and economically, the ratepayers will pick up every dollar of the estimated half billion dollar cost already incurred, of abandoning the various nuclear projects.

Then Rep Thrasher, now a Senator, once sat next to me at a committee hearing where I was about to get refunds due SMW  Florida Water customers. He told me to kill my other legislation that put more teeth into water utility laws, or he would kill the refund legislation because he was powerful enough to do it.  He did.  I am not proud that many times when I was doing my job and doing the right thing, some Republican leaders who had their own agenda, tried to neutralize me , even sending and funding republican candidate to run against me.  These people make it bad for the R party and honest republicans.

In my first few years in the Fl House Speaker Webster started to reduce our government where we could.  I had been given the task to look at DEP to see where we could gain efficiency.  We did that with all state agencies, most recently to the point that they cannot possibly do the job we ask them to.  When they inevitably fail,  legislators point to privatization.   For today’s so called leaders to pretend that this has not already been done, is a fraud. After 16 yrs of Rs leading the state, if this had not been done, why would you ever vote for a Republican again?

Today’s republican leaders demand a total bee hive mentality even as they stray further from real republican principles.   There are boys with little life experience running the 4th largest state.  While I have no doubt that the Democrat party has its problems,  I speak as a Republican who has been on the inside for a long time in the republican party.

I believe that the millions of dollars from the mega corporations that the Republican party hijackers get in their sweet sounding slush funds, like the “Committee to create a beautiful world” are given with the purpose of pushing the corporate hegemony which is advancing rapidly throughout the country. While I am not anti-corporation, I certainly do not want my country run by the mega corporations.  I see the same legislation in many states. My son and many of your sons and daughters are not serving this country in our military to hand our democracy over to mega corporations.  Veterans should be outraged.

I have never seen a more bee hive mentality with hardly any independent thoughtful thinking occurring from our elected officials.

Whether you are of a particular party, or no party, you cannot want an elected official that just follows.  Why have separate districts?  Not many of us get to vote for the leaders of any party, just for those that run from our own districts and we should expect that they remember where they came from and vote for the interests of their districts as well as the Constitution they swore to uphold.

I have been asked by many people to run for elected office again, to stay involved.  I have had inquiries to see what I have been doing.  I am still here, despite those who wish I were gone, and have been working on PSC changes I hope to gain citizen support.

I have a fire in my gut more than ever to stop the selling of our representative government; to stop the corruption and the hypocrisy; to work toward fixing the real problems we are all facing.    I cannot and will not sit and do nothing.

If belonging to a political party means having to follow blindly, count me out.  We need more citizen legislators with the courage to fly alone if the team goes in the wrong direction.   Both political parties need a re-awakening.   Perhaps in these dire times, partisan politics, is the last thing we need.

I put a lot on the line to advise you that the proposals by  young inexperienced legislative  power mongers  and  Rick Scott were going to do harm to the very people I worked hard to protect.  I warned you, Nevertheless those agendas have become policy of the state.  I believe  we have to fight hard to get our democracy back.  Our rights, our government  are worth that fight.  The time is now.

 

Nancy Argenziano

 

 

 

Share

Comments (0)

Why SunRail Should be Rejected by Governor Scott

Posted on 29 April 2011 by admin

Special Report to Central Florida Politics and Freeline Media Orlando by former Winter Park City Commissioner Beth Dilliha and Winter Park Commuter Rail Committee member George McClure.

Why SunRail Should be Rejected by Governor Scott

The proposed SunRail commuter rail project is a diesel heavy rail project (as opposed to light rail) devised to run on a 61.5-mile portion of CSX-owned rails from Volusia to Osceola counties. There would be 56 daily commuter services would run with 32 running initially. There will be no weekend or holiday service. Commuter rail would not go to the airport or attractions.  17 stations are planned over the 61.5-mile corridor.

 

The project has been fraught with problems since conception resulting in rejection by the state legislature twice. It ultimately received a green light on the third try in December of 2009 when it was tied to High Speed Rail.  Currently, Governor Scott is scrutinizing the costs, risks for cost overruns and return on investment to the taxpayers that would fund it.

 

Problems with SunRail include 1) extraordinarily high costs to build and run the system, 2) lack of a funding source for the annual operating deficits and maintenance costs, 3) grossly overestimated farebox revenues, 4) a low ridership projection of 3700, 5) low marks from the Federal Transit Authority (FTA) in terms of cost effectiveness and need, 6) old-style diesel technology, 7) shifting of liability for accidents, injuries and deaths from CSX to the Florida taxpayers, 8) lack of feeder buses to take commuters to final destinations, and 9) lack of approval or support from taxpaying voters.

 

SunRail has a first year start-up cost of $1.2 Billion. Purchasing the tracks from CSX for the highest price per mile ever paid in the U.S. is a bad idea and unnecessary, since CSX and Norfolk Southern lease access to their tracks for commuter rail in northern Virginia while retaining responsibility for maintenance. In addition, Florida taxpayers would pay 100% of the annual operating and maintenance costs for 99 years while CSX gets to use the tracks 50% of the time.

 

Operating and maintenance costs for start-up rail projects are underestimated by 40%, on average, according to APTA (American Public Transit Association). FDOT (Florida Department of Transportation) is projecting that over 50% of operating costs will be paid for with revenue from the farebox even though the national average is 23% farebox recovery.  So, we know that the revenues will be far less than estimated while annual costs will be far greater.  FTA also knows this and has required FDOT to guarantee an additional source of funding when the county caps are exceeded.  The solution, unbeknownst to Central Floridians, is to cannibalize funds from existing road and other infrastructure projects, eliminating those necessary projects. The irony is that stealing the highway money to pay SunRail costs would eliminate the I-4 improvement that commuter rail was supposed to help, by removing cars from I-4 while it was upgraded.

 

SunRail needs a full, sustained dedicated funding source for operation, but doesn’t have it.  SunRail would be funded by FDOT for the first seven years of operation, then by the four counties, Orlando, Winter Park and Maitland.  The penny sales tax that was counted on in Seminole County expires this year.  Past efforts to raise transit funds by sales tax in Orange County have failed; there is now a half-cent local option sales tax for schools. With no dedicated funding, two localities can exercise a right to drop out from service, raising the cost for the remaining fifteen stops.

 

The use of 19th century diesel locomotives for SunRail would commit Florida to technology that is fast becoming outdated.  Electrification of the commuter line (vs diesel locomotives) would permit operating electric locomotives, as is done in the northeast corridor, and as Amtrak has as a long-term goal across the United States.  That would permit service by fixed power plants with emission controls burning coal (nearly half our electricity now comes from coal-fired plants) or natural gas, or by nuclear power.

 

Another fly in the ointment is the liability insurance that CSX insists that the state buy for SunRail, and your Florida legislators approved, to cover everything except willful misconduct by the company or its employees or subsidiaries.  Note that Amtrak paid $63.8 million after an accident caused by a faulty CSX switch at Lugoff, SC, that killed eight people.   http://www.pulitzer.org/archives/6931 .

 

In summary, only 2% of Floridians use public transit. Our results for SunRail will be worse, especially if there is no funding to provide feeder buses to meet each train and carry riders in both directions (at least 112 buses per day for 56 trains. SunRail, with only 3700 projected riders, should not be allowed to cannibalize funding from planned road and other transportation projects used and needed by the vast majority. Nor, should a project with funding requirements for 99 years be allowed to be approved without first obtaining a sustainable and dedicated source of funding.  And the voting taxpayers are entitled to decide whether this is an appropriate use of their scarce taxpayer dollars.  This is an ill-conceived project that should be killed.

 

This article was written and contributed by George McClure, former member of the Winter Park Commuter Rail Task Force and Beth Dillaha, former Winter Park City Commissioner.

 

Share

Comments (0)

State Attorney and Judge Defy Federal Court Order in continuing First Amendment Prosecution.

Posted on 27 April 2011 by admin

Showdown over judge’s order slated for Thursday.

April 25th, 2011 Freeline Media

(Orlando)  Orange-Osceola State Attorney Lawson Lamar and Orange-Osceola Circuit Judge Jeffrey Arnold are both moving forward on a prosecution that has been barred by a Federal Judge.

Lamar and Arnold have chosen to openly defy a federal court injunction issued by the Chief Judge of the Northern Federal District of Florida Stephen J. Mickle that expressly prohibits any enforcement of the state’s now defunct statute regulating so-called “electioneering” political speech.  Judge Mickle declared the statute to be an “unconstitutional restriction of the First Amendment” when he threw out the statute and declared it unconstitutional in a May 22, 2009 ruling.

In his 2009 ruling, Mickle stated, “Defendants, and their officers, agents, servants, employees, and attorneys, as well as those persons in active concert or participation with them are permanently enjoined from enforcing Florida’s electioneering communications laws of Chapter 106, as listed above.”

Mickle, a highly respected Judge, enjoined the state from any enforcement of the statute.   The State of Florida dropped its appeal of the ruling and the statute was removed from the law and no longer exists.

Orlando-based talk show host and Florida’s top anti-tax crusader, Doug Guetzloe, was relieved to hear that the statute was declared unconstitutional and was pleased that longtime political opponent Lamar, who Guetzloe calls the “most corrupt state attorney in Florida,” would have to drop his prosecution of Guetzloe for a misdemeanor violation of the state law that formally required a written disclaimer on all political literature.

Guetzloe was prosecuted in 2006 for violating the now-defunct statute by failing to include a seven word disclaimer; “paid political advertisement approved by …”  Guetzloe had published a police arrest report on a candidate who had invited his neighbor over to his house and then spread dog feces all over his neighbors face and neck.

The candidate involved was charged with felony assault and battery and the police report was distributed to voters lacking the disclaimer due to a printer’s error.  The felony charges were dropped by State Attorney Lamar, a longtime friend of the candidate involved.

Guetzloe says, “I’m the only person in United States history charged criminally with not putting seven words on a political flyer.” Guetzloe also cites a “twenty year history of prosecution by longtime political nemesis Lamar” that includes dozens of investigations, charges and allegations, all disproven or dropped.

The United States Supreme court has long held that the state has no interest in requiring political disclaimers from individuals who chose to become involved in the political process.  In the landmark case, McIntyre vs. Ohio, the court ruled unconstitutional any state requirements of disclosure.

Judge Jeff Arnold, openly defying the federal court order, has sentenced Guetzloe to sixty days in jail and a $1000 fine for the unique misdemeanor charge that no longer exists in the statutes.

Arnold has scheduled a “sentencing hearing” on Thursday, April 28th ostensibly to continue the prosecution of the statute that no longer exists and order Guetzloe to jail.

Constitutional attorney Frederic B. O’Neal has filed an emergency motion with the Federal court to alert Judge Mickle to this violation of his order.

“This is a small price to pay for defending the First Amendment, but to have the spectacle of being ordered to jail over a statute that has been declared unconstitutional by a federal judge by a local judge and a state attorney both enjoined from moving forward, is clearly a miscarriage of justice,” Guetzloe said.

Governor Rick Scott is reviewing the case for possible gubernatorial intervention.

Published by Freeline Media Orlando at Freeline Media Orlando – April 25, 2011

www.FreelineMediaOrlando.com

 

Share

Comments (0)

State Attorney and Judge Defy Federal Court Order in continuing First Amendment Prosecution

Posted on 27 April 2011 by admin

Showdown over judge’s order slated for Thursday.

April 25th, 2011 Freeline Media

(Orlando)  Orange-Osceola State Attorney Lawson Lamar and Orange-Osceola Circuit Judge Jeffrey Arnold are both moving forward on a prosecution that has been barred by a Federal Judge.

Lamar and Arnold have chosen to openly defy a federal court injunction issued by the Chief Judge of the Northern Federal District of Florida Stephen J. Mickle that expressly prohibits any enforcement of the state’s now defunct statute regulating so-called “electioneering” political speech.  Judge Mickle declared the statute to be an “unconstitutional restriction of the First Amendment” when he threw out the statute and declared it unconstitutional in a May 22, 2009 ruling.

In his 2009 ruling, Mickle stated, “Defendants, and their officers, agents, servants, employees, and attorneys, as well as those persons in active concert or participation with them are permanently enjoined from enforcing Florida’s electioneering communications laws of Chapter 106, as listed above.”

Mickle, a highly respected Judge, enjoined the state from any enforcement of the statute.   The State of Florida dropped its appeal of the ruling and the statute was removed from the law and no longer exists.

Orlando-based talk show host and Florida’s top anti-tax crusader, Doug Guetzloe, was relieved to hear that the statute was declared unconstitutional and was pleased that longtime political opponent Lamar, who Guetzloe calls the “most corrupt state attorney in Florida,” would have to drop his prosecution of Guetzloe for a misdemeanor violation of the state law that formally required a written disclaimer on all political literature.

Guetzloe was prosecuted in 2006 for violating the now-defunct statute by failing to include a seven word disclaimer; “paid political advertisement approved by …”  Guetzloe had published a police arrest report on a candidate who had invited his neighbor over to his house and then spread dog feces all over his neighbors face and neck.

The candidate involved was charged with felony assault and battery and the police report was distributed to voters lacking the disclaimer due to a printer’s error.  The felony charges were dropped by State Attorney Lamar, a longtime friend of the candidate involved.

Guetzloe says, “I’m the only person in United States history charged criminally with not putting seven words on a political flyer.” Guetzloe also cites a “twenty year history of prosecution by longtime political nemesis Lamar” that includes dozens of investigations, charges and allegations, all disproven or dropped.

The United States Supreme court has long held that the state has no interest in requiring political disclaimers from individuals who chose to become involved in the political process.  In the landmark case, McIntyre vs. Ohio, the court ruled unconstitutional any state requirements of disclosure.

Judge Jeff Arnold, openly defying the federal court order, has sentenced Guetzloe to sixty days in jail and a $1000 fine for the unique misdemeanor charge that no longer exists in the statutes.

Arnold has scheduled a “sentencing hearing” on Thursday, April 28th ostensibly to continue the prosecution of the statute that no longer exists and order Guetzloe to jail.

Constitutional attorney Frederic B. O’Neal has filed an emergency motion with the Federal court to alert Judge Mickle to this violation of his order.

“This is a small price to pay for defending the First Amendment, but to have the spectacle of being ordered to jail over a statute that has been declared unconstitutional by a federal judge by a local judge and a state attorney both enjoined from moving forward, is clearly a miscarriage of justice,” Guetzloe said.

Governor Rick Scott is reviewing the case for possible gubernatorial intervention.

Published by Freeline Media Orlando at Freeline Media Orlando – April 25, 2011

www.FreelineMediaOrlando.com

 

Share

Comments (0)

Advertise Here
Advertise Here

Photos from our Flickr stream

See all photos

Advertise Here

Click here to buy the DVD!